Comparing DPC, APC, and PCMH: Which Primary Care Model Fits Best with ICHRA?

Choosing the right primary care model to pair with an Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement (ICHRA) can be a game-changer for employers and benefits brokers. With options like Direct Primary Care (DPC), Advanced Primary Care (APC), and the Patient-Centered Medical Home (PCMH) available, understanding the differences and how each fits with ICHRA is key. This article breaks down each model, highlights their unique features, and explains how they work together with ICHRA to deliver value, flexibility, and better health outcomes.

Understanding ICHRA and Primary Care Models

ICHRA is a modern health benefits solution that lets employers reimburse employees for individual health insurance and qualified medical expenses with pre-tax dollars. It’s designed for flexibility, cost control, and choice—putting employees in charge of their own health coverage. When paired with innovative primary care models like DPC, APC, or PCMH, ICHRA helps employers build a benefits package that stands out in today’s competitive market.

What Is Direct Primary Care (DPC)?

Direct Primary Care (DPC) is a healthcare model where patients pay a flat monthly fee directly to a primary care provider. This fee covers most primary care services, including office visits, basic lab work, and quick access to doctors—often via phone, text, or video chat. DPC providers typically have fewer patients, which means more time for each appointment and a strong focus on preventive care.

Key Features of DPC:

• No insurance billing: Patients pay a monthly membership fee, not per visit.
• Personalized care: Fewer patients per provider means more attention and longer appointments.
• Affordable access: Predictable pricing and no copays or deductibles for covered services.

DPC is not health insurance, but it can be paired with ICHRA to give employees affordable, high-quality primary care and help them save their ICHRA dollars for other medical needs.

What Is Advanced Primary Care (APC)?

Advanced Primary Care (APC) is a model that builds on the DPC approach by adding technology, data-driven insights, and a focus on population health. APC providers use evidence-based practices, predictive analytics, and team-based care to improve outcomes and lower costs. The goal is to keep patients healthy and out of the hospital through proactive management and coordination.

Key Features of APC:

• Team-based care: Multiple providers work together to manage patient health.
• Data-driven: Uses technology and analytics to track and improve health outcomes.
• Population health focus: Looks at the health of groups, not just individuals, to prevent disease and reduce costs.

APC is ideal for employers who want to go beyond basic primary care and invest in long-term health improvements for their workforce.

What Is Patient-Centered Medical Home (PCMH)?

Patient-Centered Medical Home (PCMH) is a care delivery model that organizes primary care around the patient. In a PCMH, a team of providers coordinates all aspects of a patient’s care, from preventive services to specialist referrals. The focus is on quality, access, and patient engagement.

Key Features of PCMH:

• Centralized care: All primary care services are provided in one place.
• Coordinated care: Providers work together to manage patient health and connect with specialists as needed.
• Evidence-based: Care is guided by research and best practices.

PCMH is recognized for improving outcomes, reducing hospitalizations, and lowering costs by keeping patients healthy and well-managed.

APC vs. PCMH: Key Differences and Overlaps

A common misconception is that APC and PCMH are the same. While they share many principles—such as team-based care, coordination, and a focus on quality—they are not identical:

‍

Recent policy and program guidance, such as New York State’s transition from APC to NYS PCMH, highlight that while APC and PCMH share many goals, their criteria and documentation requirements do not always align perfectly. APC can partially fulfill PCMH requirements, but additional documentation or processes may be needed for formal PCMH recognition.

How DPC, APC, and PCMH Work with ICHRA

Pairing ICHRA with the right primary care model can create a powerful benefits package. Here’s how each model fits with ICHRA:

• DPC and ICHRA:. Employers may bundle DPC membership fees with ICHRA plans to create a comprehensive benefits program.
• APC and ICHRA: APC’s data-driven, team-based approach helps employers manage health risks and reduce costs; ICHRA funds may be used for eligible services and technology-enabled care.
• PCMH and ICHRA: PCMH’s focus on patient-centered, coordinated care aligns with ICHRA’s flexibility, allowing reimbursement for eligible services and care coordination.

Key Takeaways

• DPC is best for employers who want affordable, personalized primary care with easy access.
• APC is ideal for employers focused on data-driven, team-based care and population health.
• PCMH is the right choice for employers who value coordinated, patient-centered care and quality outcomes.
• APC and PCMH are related but not the same: PCMH is a structured, recognized model; APC is a broader, evolving approach that may incorporate PCMH principles but is not limited to them.
• ICHRA gives employees the freedom to choose their own health plans and services, while employers benefit from cost control and administrative simplicity.

By understanding the strengths of each primary care model and how they fit with ICHRA, benefits brokers and employers can design benefits packages that meet the needs of today’s workforce and deliver real value.